Two policies can have the same dwelling limit and pay very different amounts for the same fire. The difference is the settlement basis: the rule the policy uses to value what was lost. Manufactured home policies commonly offer three.
Replacement cost
Pays the cost to repair or replace the damaged property with similar new materials or a similar new home, without deducting for depreciation, up to the policy limit and subject to the policy's conditions. Many replacement cost forms pay the actual cash value first and the remaining amount once the repair or replacement is completed.
Best for: homeowners who want to be able to rebuild or replace without paying the depreciation gap themselves. Costs more than actual cash value because the insurer's exposure is higher.
Actual cash value
Pays the replacement cost minus depreciation for age, wear, and condition. For an older home or older belongings, depreciation can be a large share of the value.
Illustration (not a quote): a similar home would cost $90,000 to replace today. If the insurer determines that age and wear have reduced the destroyed home's value by 20 percent, the settlement before the deductible would be about $72,000. The actual calculation depends on the policy and the adjuster's evaluation.
Best for: lower premiums where the homeowner accepts carrying the depreciation gap, or where replacement cost is not offered for the home's age.
Agreed value
For a total loss, pays the amount shown on the policy as the agreed value, without a depreciation calculation at the time of loss. Partial losses are settled under the policy's repair provisions, which may use replacement cost or actual cash value.
Best for: homeowners who want certainty about a total loss payout. It is important that the agreed amount tracks the home's real replacement value; too low and you are underinsured, too high and you pay premium for coverage you cannot collect.
Contents are settled too
The same choice applies separately to personal property. A policy can settle the home on replacement cost and the contents on actual cash value, or offer replacement cost on contents as an endorsement. Ask which basis applies to each.
How to choose
- Ask what each basis costs for your home. The premium difference is often smaller than the claim difference.
- Match the dwelling limit to today's replacement value, whichever basis you choose.
- Check whether replacement cost or agreed value is available for your home's age; older homes may have fewer options.
- Read how partial losses are settled on an agreed value form.
- Revisit the limit at renewal; construction costs move.
We quote the options side by side so you can see the premium and the claim difference together. Request a quote or call 714-731-8080.



